1 // Copyright (c) 2015-2016 The Khronos Group Inc.
2 //
3 // Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
4 // you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
5 // You may obtain a copy of the License at
6 //
7 // http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
8 //
9 // Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
10 // distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
11 // WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
12 // See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
13 // limitations under the License.
14
15 // Performs validation on instructions that appear inside of a SPIR-V block.
16
17 #include "source/val/validate.h"
18
19 #include <algorithm>
20 #include <cassert>
21 #include <sstream>
22 #include <string>
23 #include <vector>
24
25 #include "source/binary.h"
26 #include "source/diagnostic.h"
27 #include "source/enum_set.h"
28 #include "source/enum_string_mapping.h"
29 #include "source/extensions.h"
30 #include "source/opcode.h"
31 #include "source/operand.h"
32 #include "source/spirv_constant.h"
33 #include "source/spirv_definition.h"
34 #include "source/spirv_target_env.h"
35 #include "source/spirv_validator_options.h"
36 #include "source/util/string_utils.h"
37 #include "source/val/function.h"
38 #include "source/val/validation_state.h"
39
40 namespace spvtools {
41 namespace val {
42 namespace {
43
ToString(const CapabilitySet & capabilities,const AssemblyGrammar & grammar)44 std::string ToString(const CapabilitySet& capabilities,
45 const AssemblyGrammar& grammar) {
46 std::stringstream ss;
47 capabilities.ForEach([&grammar, &ss](SpvCapability cap) {
48 spv_operand_desc desc;
49 if (SPV_SUCCESS ==
50 grammar.lookupOperand(SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_CAPABILITY, cap, &desc))
51 ss << desc->name << " ";
52 else
53 ss << cap << " ";
54 });
55 return ss.str();
56 }
57
58 // Returns capabilities that enable an opcode. An empty result is interpreted
59 // as no prohibition of use of the opcode. If the result is non-empty, then
60 // the opcode may only be used if at least one of the capabilities is specified
61 // by the module.
EnablingCapabilitiesForOp(const ValidationState_t & state,SpvOp opcode)62 CapabilitySet EnablingCapabilitiesForOp(const ValidationState_t& state,
63 SpvOp opcode) {
64 // Exceptions for SPV_AMD_shader_ballot
65 switch (opcode) {
66 // Normally these would require Group capability
67 case SpvOpGroupIAddNonUniformAMD:
68 case SpvOpGroupFAddNonUniformAMD:
69 case SpvOpGroupFMinNonUniformAMD:
70 case SpvOpGroupUMinNonUniformAMD:
71 case SpvOpGroupSMinNonUniformAMD:
72 case SpvOpGroupFMaxNonUniformAMD:
73 case SpvOpGroupUMaxNonUniformAMD:
74 case SpvOpGroupSMaxNonUniformAMD:
75 if (state.HasExtension(kSPV_AMD_shader_ballot)) return CapabilitySet();
76 break;
77 default:
78 break;
79 }
80 // Look it up in the grammar
81 spv_opcode_desc opcode_desc = {};
82 if (SPV_SUCCESS == state.grammar().lookupOpcode(opcode, &opcode_desc)) {
83 return state.grammar().filterCapsAgainstTargetEnv(
84 opcode_desc->capabilities, opcode_desc->numCapabilities);
85 }
86 return CapabilitySet();
87 }
88
89 // Returns SPV_SUCCESS if the given operand is enabled by capabilities declared
90 // in the module. Otherwise issues an error message and returns
91 // SPV_ERROR_INVALID_CAPABILITY.
CheckRequiredCapabilities(ValidationState_t & state,const Instruction * inst,size_t which_operand,spv_operand_type_t type,uint32_t operand)92 spv_result_t CheckRequiredCapabilities(ValidationState_t& state,
93 const Instruction* inst,
94 size_t which_operand,
95 spv_operand_type_t type,
96 uint32_t operand) {
97 // Mere mention of PointSize, ClipDistance, or CullDistance in a Builtin
98 // decoration does not require the associated capability. The use of such
99 // a variable value should trigger the capability requirement, but that's
100 // not implemented yet. This rule is independent of target environment.
101 // See https://github.com/KhronosGroup/SPIRV-Tools/issues/365
102 if (type == SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_BUILT_IN) {
103 switch (operand) {
104 case SpvBuiltInPointSize:
105 case SpvBuiltInClipDistance:
106 case SpvBuiltInCullDistance:
107 return SPV_SUCCESS;
108 default:
109 break;
110 }
111 } else if (type == SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_FP_ROUNDING_MODE) {
112 // Allow all FP rounding modes if requested
113 if (state.features().free_fp_rounding_mode) {
114 return SPV_SUCCESS;
115 }
116 } else if (type == SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_GROUP_OPERATION &&
117 state.features().group_ops_reduce_and_scans &&
118 (operand <= uint32_t(SpvGroupOperationExclusiveScan))) {
119 // Allow certain group operations if requested.
120 return SPV_SUCCESS;
121 }
122
123 CapabilitySet enabling_capabilities;
124 spv_operand_desc operand_desc = nullptr;
125 const auto lookup_result =
126 state.grammar().lookupOperand(type, operand, &operand_desc);
127 if (lookup_result == SPV_SUCCESS) {
128 // Allow FPRoundingMode decoration if requested.
129 if (type == SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_DECORATION &&
130 operand_desc->value == SpvDecorationFPRoundingMode) {
131 if (state.features().free_fp_rounding_mode) return SPV_SUCCESS;
132
133 // Vulkan API requires more capabilities on rounding mode.
134 if (spvIsVulkanEnv(state.context()->target_env)) {
135 enabling_capabilities.Add(SpvCapabilityStorageUniformBufferBlock16);
136 enabling_capabilities.Add(SpvCapabilityStorageUniform16);
137 enabling_capabilities.Add(SpvCapabilityStoragePushConstant16);
138 enabling_capabilities.Add(SpvCapabilityStorageInputOutput16);
139 }
140 } else {
141 enabling_capabilities = state.grammar().filterCapsAgainstTargetEnv(
142 operand_desc->capabilities, operand_desc->numCapabilities);
143 }
144
145 if (!state.HasAnyOfCapabilities(enabling_capabilities)) {
146 return state.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_CAPABILITY, inst)
147 << "Operand " << which_operand << " of "
148 << spvOpcodeString(inst->opcode())
149 << " requires one of these capabilities: "
150 << ToString(enabling_capabilities, state.grammar());
151 }
152 }
153
154 return SPV_SUCCESS;
155 }
156
157 // Returns operand's required extensions.
RequiredExtensions(const ValidationState_t & state,spv_operand_type_t type,uint32_t operand)158 ExtensionSet RequiredExtensions(const ValidationState_t& state,
159 spv_operand_type_t type, uint32_t operand) {
160 spv_operand_desc operand_desc;
161 if (state.grammar().lookupOperand(type, operand, &operand_desc) ==
162 SPV_SUCCESS) {
163 assert(operand_desc);
164 // If this operand is incorporated into core SPIR-V before or in the current
165 // target environment, we don't require extensions anymore.
166 if (spvVersionForTargetEnv(state.grammar().target_env()) >=
167 operand_desc->minVersion)
168 return {};
169 return {operand_desc->numExtensions, operand_desc->extensions};
170 }
171
172 return {};
173 }
174
175 // Returns SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY and emits a diagnostic if the instruction
176 // is explicitly reserved in the SPIR-V core spec. Otherwise return
177 // SPV_SUCCESS.
ReservedCheck(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)178 spv_result_t ReservedCheck(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
179 const SpvOp opcode = inst->opcode();
180 switch (opcode) {
181 // These instructions are enabled by a capability, but should never
182 // be used anyway.
183 case SpvOpImageSparseSampleProjImplicitLod:
184 case SpvOpImageSparseSampleProjExplicitLod:
185 case SpvOpImageSparseSampleProjDrefImplicitLod:
186 case SpvOpImageSparseSampleProjDrefExplicitLod: {
187 spv_opcode_desc inst_desc;
188 _.grammar().lookupOpcode(opcode, &inst_desc);
189 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
190 << "Invalid Opcode name 'Op" << inst_desc->name << "'";
191 }
192 default:
193 break;
194 }
195 return SPV_SUCCESS;
196 }
197
198 // Returns SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY and emits a diagnostic if the instruction
199 // is invalid because of an execution environment constraint.
EnvironmentCheck(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)200 spv_result_t EnvironmentCheck(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
201 const SpvOp opcode = inst->opcode();
202 switch (opcode) {
203 case SpvOpUndef:
204 if (_.features().bans_op_undef) {
205 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
206 << "OpUndef is disallowed";
207 }
208 break;
209 default:
210 break;
211 }
212 return SPV_SUCCESS;
213 }
214
215 // Returns SPV_ERROR_INVALID_CAPABILITY and emits a diagnostic if the
216 // instruction is invalid because the required capability isn't declared
217 // in the module.
CapabilityCheck(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)218 spv_result_t CapabilityCheck(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
219 const SpvOp opcode = inst->opcode();
220 CapabilitySet opcode_caps = EnablingCapabilitiesForOp(_, opcode);
221 if (!_.HasAnyOfCapabilities(opcode_caps)) {
222 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_CAPABILITY, inst)
223 << "Opcode " << spvOpcodeString(opcode)
224 << " requires one of these capabilities: "
225 << ToString(opcode_caps, _.grammar());
226 }
227 for (size_t i = 0; i < inst->operands().size(); ++i) {
228 const auto& operand = inst->operand(i);
229 const auto word = inst->word(operand.offset);
230 if (spvOperandIsConcreteMask(operand.type)) {
231 // Check for required capabilities for each bit position of the mask.
232 for (uint32_t mask_bit = 0x80000000; mask_bit; mask_bit >>= 1) {
233 if (word & mask_bit) {
234 spv_result_t status =
235 CheckRequiredCapabilities(_, inst, i + 1, operand.type, mask_bit);
236 if (status != SPV_SUCCESS) return status;
237 }
238 }
239 } else if (spvIsIdType(operand.type)) {
240 // TODO(dneto): Check the value referenced by this Id, if we can compute
241 // it. For now, just punt, to fix issue 248:
242 // https://github.com/KhronosGroup/SPIRV-Tools/issues/248
243 } else {
244 // Check the operand word as a whole.
245 spv_result_t status =
246 CheckRequiredCapabilities(_, inst, i + 1, operand.type, word);
247 if (status != SPV_SUCCESS) return status;
248 }
249 }
250 return SPV_SUCCESS;
251 }
252
253 // Checks that all extensions required by the given instruction's operands were
254 // declared in the module.
ExtensionCheck(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)255 spv_result_t ExtensionCheck(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
256 const SpvOp opcode = inst->opcode();
257 for (size_t operand_index = 0; operand_index < inst->operands().size();
258 ++operand_index) {
259 const auto& operand = inst->operand(operand_index);
260 const uint32_t word = inst->word(operand.offset);
261 const ExtensionSet required_extensions =
262 RequiredExtensions(_, operand.type, word);
263 if (!_.HasAnyOfExtensions(required_extensions)) {
264 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_MISSING_EXTENSION, inst)
265 << spvtools::utils::CardinalToOrdinal(operand_index + 1)
266 << " operand of " << spvOpcodeString(opcode) << ": operand "
267 << word << " requires one of these extensions: "
268 << ExtensionSetToString(required_extensions);
269 }
270 }
271 return SPV_SUCCESS;
272 }
273
274 // Checks that the instruction can be used in this target environment's base
275 // version. Assumes that CapabilityCheck has checked direct capability
276 // dependencies for the opcode.
VersionCheck(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)277 spv_result_t VersionCheck(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
278 const auto opcode = inst->opcode();
279 spv_opcode_desc inst_desc;
280 const spv_result_t r = _.grammar().lookupOpcode(opcode, &inst_desc);
281 assert(r == SPV_SUCCESS);
282 (void)r;
283
284 const auto min_version = inst_desc->minVersion;
285
286 if (inst_desc->numCapabilities > 0u) {
287 // We already checked that the direct capability dependency has been
288 // satisfied. We don't need to check any further.
289 return SPV_SUCCESS;
290 }
291
292 ExtensionSet exts(inst_desc->numExtensions, inst_desc->extensions);
293 if (exts.IsEmpty()) {
294 // If no extensions can enable this instruction, then emit error messages
295 // only concerning core SPIR-V versions if errors happen.
296 if (min_version == ~0u) {
297 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_WRONG_VERSION, inst)
298 << spvOpcodeString(opcode) << " is reserved for future use.";
299 }
300
301 if (spvVersionForTargetEnv(_.grammar().target_env()) < min_version) {
302 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_WRONG_VERSION, inst)
303 << spvOpcodeString(opcode) << " requires "
304 << spvTargetEnvDescription(
305 static_cast<spv_target_env>(min_version))
306 << " at minimum.";
307 }
308 // Otherwise, we only error out when no enabling extensions are registered.
309 } else if (!_.HasAnyOfExtensions(exts)) {
310 if (min_version == ~0u) {
311 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_MISSING_EXTENSION, inst)
312 << spvOpcodeString(opcode)
313 << " requires one of the following extensions: "
314 << ExtensionSetToString(exts);
315 }
316
317 if (static_cast<uint32_t>(_.grammar().target_env()) < min_version) {
318 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_WRONG_VERSION, inst)
319 << spvOpcodeString(opcode) << " requires "
320 << spvTargetEnvDescription(
321 static_cast<spv_target_env>(min_version))
322 << " at minimum or one of the following extensions: "
323 << ExtensionSetToString(exts);
324 }
325 }
326
327 return SPV_SUCCESS;
328 }
329
330 // Checks that the Resuld <id> is within the valid bound.
LimitCheckIdBound(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)331 spv_result_t LimitCheckIdBound(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
332 if (inst->id() >= _.getIdBound()) {
333 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
334 << "Result <id> '" << inst->id()
335 << "' must be less than the ID bound '" << _.getIdBound() << "'.";
336 }
337 return SPV_SUCCESS;
338 }
339
340 // Checks that the number of OpTypeStruct members is within the limit.
LimitCheckStruct(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)341 spv_result_t LimitCheckStruct(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
342 if (SpvOpTypeStruct != inst->opcode()) {
343 return SPV_SUCCESS;
344 }
345
346 // Number of members is the number of operands of the instruction minus 1.
347 // One operand is the result ID.
348 const uint16_t limit =
349 static_cast<uint16_t>(_.options()->universal_limits_.max_struct_members);
350 if (inst->operands().size() - 1 > limit) {
351 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
352 << "Number of OpTypeStruct members (" << inst->operands().size() - 1
353 << ") has exceeded the limit (" << limit << ").";
354 }
355
356 // Section 2.17 of SPIRV Spec specifies that the "Structure Nesting Depth"
357 // must be less than or equal to 255.
358 // This is interpreted as structures including other structures as members.
359 // The code does not follow pointers or look into arrays to see if we reach a
360 // structure downstream.
361 // The nesting depth of a struct is 1+(largest depth of any member).
362 // Scalars are at depth 0.
363 uint32_t max_member_depth = 0;
364 // Struct members start at word 2 of OpTypeStruct instruction.
365 for (size_t word_i = 2; word_i < inst->words().size(); ++word_i) {
366 auto member = inst->word(word_i);
367 auto memberTypeInstr = _.FindDef(member);
368 if (memberTypeInstr && SpvOpTypeStruct == memberTypeInstr->opcode()) {
369 max_member_depth = std::max(
370 max_member_depth, _.struct_nesting_depth(memberTypeInstr->id()));
371 }
372 }
373
374 const uint32_t depth_limit = _.options()->universal_limits_.max_struct_depth;
375 const uint32_t cur_depth = 1 + max_member_depth;
376 _.set_struct_nesting_depth(inst->id(), cur_depth);
377 if (cur_depth > depth_limit) {
378 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
379 << "Structure Nesting Depth may not be larger than " << depth_limit
380 << ". Found " << cur_depth << ".";
381 }
382 return SPV_SUCCESS;
383 }
384
385 // Checks that the number of (literal, label) pairs in OpSwitch is within the
386 // limit.
LimitCheckSwitch(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)387 spv_result_t LimitCheckSwitch(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
388 if (SpvOpSwitch == inst->opcode()) {
389 // The instruction syntax is as follows:
390 // OpSwitch <selector ID> <Default ID> literal label literal label ...
391 // literal,label pairs come after the first 2 operands.
392 // It is guaranteed at this point that num_operands is an even numner.
393 size_t num_pairs = (inst->operands().size() - 2) / 2;
394 const unsigned int num_pairs_limit =
395 _.options()->universal_limits_.max_switch_branches;
396 if (num_pairs > num_pairs_limit) {
397 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
398 << "Number of (literal, label) pairs in OpSwitch (" << num_pairs
399 << ") exceeds the limit (" << num_pairs_limit << ").";
400 }
401 }
402 return SPV_SUCCESS;
403 }
404
405 // Ensure the number of variables of the given class does not exceed the limit.
LimitCheckNumVars(ValidationState_t & _,const uint32_t var_id,const SpvStorageClass storage_class)406 spv_result_t LimitCheckNumVars(ValidationState_t& _, const uint32_t var_id,
407 const SpvStorageClass storage_class) {
408 if (SpvStorageClassFunction == storage_class) {
409 _.registerLocalVariable(var_id);
410 const uint32_t num_local_vars_limit =
411 _.options()->universal_limits_.max_local_variables;
412 if (_.num_local_vars() > num_local_vars_limit) {
413 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, nullptr)
414 << "Number of local variables ('Function' Storage Class) "
415 "exceeded the valid limit ("
416 << num_local_vars_limit << ").";
417 }
418 } else {
419 _.registerGlobalVariable(var_id);
420 const uint32_t num_global_vars_limit =
421 _.options()->universal_limits_.max_global_variables;
422 if (_.num_global_vars() > num_global_vars_limit) {
423 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, nullptr)
424 << "Number of Global Variables (Storage Class other than "
425 "'Function') exceeded the valid limit ("
426 << num_global_vars_limit << ").";
427 }
428 }
429 return SPV_SUCCESS;
430 }
431
432 // Parses OpExtension instruction and logs warnings if unsuccessful.
CheckIfKnownExtension(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)433 spv_result_t CheckIfKnownExtension(ValidationState_t& _,
434 const Instruction* inst) {
435 const std::string extension_str = GetExtensionString(&(inst->c_inst()));
436 Extension extension;
437 if (!GetExtensionFromString(extension_str.c_str(), &extension)) {
438 return _.diag(SPV_WARNING, inst)
439 << "Found unrecognized extension " << extension_str;
440 }
441 return SPV_SUCCESS;
442 }
443
444 } // namespace
445
InstructionPass(ValidationState_t & _,const Instruction * inst)446 spv_result_t InstructionPass(ValidationState_t& _, const Instruction* inst) {
447 const SpvOp opcode = inst->opcode();
448 if (opcode == SpvOpExtension) {
449 CheckIfKnownExtension(_, inst);
450 } else if (opcode == SpvOpCapability) {
451 _.RegisterCapability(inst->GetOperandAs<SpvCapability>(0));
452 } else if (opcode == SpvOpMemoryModel) {
453 if (_.has_memory_model_specified()) {
454 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_LAYOUT, inst)
455 << "OpMemoryModel should only be provided once.";
456 }
457 _.set_addressing_model(inst->GetOperandAs<SpvAddressingModel>(0));
458 _.set_memory_model(inst->GetOperandAs<SpvMemoryModel>(1));
459
460 if (_.memory_model() != SpvMemoryModelVulkanKHR &&
461 _.HasCapability(SpvCapabilityVulkanMemoryModelKHR)) {
462 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_DATA, inst)
463 << "VulkanMemoryModelKHR capability must only be specified if the "
464 "VulkanKHR memory model is used.";
465 }
466
467 if (spvIsWebGPUEnv(_.context()->target_env)) {
468 if (_.addressing_model() != SpvAddressingModelLogical) {
469 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_DATA, inst)
470 << "Addressing model must be Logical for WebGPU environment.";
471 }
472 if (_.memory_model() != SpvMemoryModelVulkanKHR) {
473 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_DATA, inst)
474 << "Memory model must be VulkanKHR for WebGPU environment.";
475 }
476 }
477 } else if (opcode == SpvOpExecutionMode) {
478 const uint32_t entry_point = inst->word(1);
479 _.RegisterExecutionModeForEntryPoint(entry_point,
480 SpvExecutionMode(inst->word(2)));
481 } else if (opcode == SpvOpVariable) {
482 const auto storage_class = inst->GetOperandAs<SpvStorageClass>(2);
483 if (auto error = LimitCheckNumVars(_, inst->id(), storage_class)) {
484 return error;
485 }
486 if (storage_class == SpvStorageClassGeneric)
487 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
488 << "OpVariable storage class cannot be Generic";
489 if (_.current_layout_section() == kLayoutFunctionDefinitions) {
490 if (storage_class != SpvStorageClassFunction) {
491 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_LAYOUT, inst)
492 << "Variables must have a function[7] storage class inside"
493 " of a function";
494 }
495 if (_.current_function().IsFirstBlock(
496 _.current_function().current_block()->id()) == false) {
497 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_CFG, inst)
498 << "Variables can only be defined "
499 "in the first block of a "
500 "function";
501 }
502 } else {
503 if (storage_class == SpvStorageClassFunction) {
504 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_LAYOUT, inst)
505 << "Variables can not have a function[7] storage class "
506 "outside of a function";
507 }
508 }
509 }
510
511 // SPIR-V Spec 2.16.3: Validation Rules for Kernel Capabilities: The
512 // Signedness in OpTypeInt must always be 0.
513 if (SpvOpTypeInt == inst->opcode() && _.HasCapability(SpvCapabilityKernel) &&
514 inst->GetOperandAs<uint32_t>(2) != 0u) {
515 return _.diag(SPV_ERROR_INVALID_BINARY, inst)
516 << "The Signedness in OpTypeInt "
517 "must always be 0 when Kernel "
518 "capability is used.";
519 }
520
521 if (auto error = ExtensionCheck(_, inst)) return error;
522 if (auto error = ReservedCheck(_, inst)) return error;
523 if (auto error = EnvironmentCheck(_, inst)) return error;
524 if (auto error = CapabilityCheck(_, inst)) return error;
525 if (auto error = LimitCheckIdBound(_, inst)) return error;
526 if (auto error = LimitCheckStruct(_, inst)) return error;
527 if (auto error = LimitCheckSwitch(_, inst)) return error;
528 if (auto error = VersionCheck(_, inst)) return error;
529
530 // All instruction checks have passed.
531 return SPV_SUCCESS;
532 }
533
534 } // namespace val
535 } // namespace spvtools
536