1 //
2 // Copyright (C) 2012 The Android Open Source Project
3 //
4 // Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
5 // you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
6 // You may obtain a copy of the License at
7 //
8 //      http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
9 //
10 // Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
11 // distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
12 // WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
13 // See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
14 // limitations under the License.
15 //
16 
17 #include "update_engine/cros/p2p_manager.h"
18 
19 #include <dirent.h>
20 #include <fcntl.h>
21 #include <sys/stat.h>
22 #include <sys/types.h>
23 #include <sys/xattr.h>
24 #include <unistd.h>
25 
26 #include <memory>
27 #include <string>
28 #include <vector>
29 
30 #include <base/bind.h>
31 #include <base/callback.h>
32 #include <base/files/file_util.h>
33 #if BASE_VER < 780000  // Android
34 #include <base/message_loop/message_loop.h>
35 #endif  // BASE_VER < 780000
36 #include <base/strings/stringprintf.h>
37 #if BASE_VER >= 780000  // CrOS
38 #include <base/task/single_thread_task_executor.h>
39 #endif  // BASE_VER >= 780000
40 #include <brillo/asynchronous_signal_handler.h>
41 #include <brillo/message_loops/base_message_loop.h>
42 #include <brillo/message_loops/message_loop.h>
43 #include <brillo/message_loops/message_loop_utils.h>
44 #include <gmock/gmock.h>
45 #include <gtest/gtest.h>
46 #include <policy/libpolicy.h>
47 #include <policy/mock_device_policy.h>
48 
49 #include "update_engine/common/prefs.h"
50 #include "update_engine/common/subprocess.h"
51 #include "update_engine/common/test_utils.h"
52 #include "update_engine/common/utils.h"
53 #include "update_engine/cros/fake_p2p_manager_configuration.h"
54 #include "update_engine/cros/fake_system_state.h"
55 #include "update_engine/update_manager/fake_update_manager.h"
56 #include "update_engine/update_manager/mock_policy.h"
57 
58 using base::TimeDelta;
59 using brillo::MessageLoop;
60 using std::string;
61 using std::unique_ptr;
62 using std::vector;
63 using testing::_;
64 using testing::DoAll;
65 using testing::Return;
66 using testing::SetArgPointee;
67 
68 namespace chromeos_update_engine {
69 
70 // Test fixture that sets up a testing configuration (with e.g. a
71 // temporary p2p dir) for P2PManager and cleans up when the test is
72 // done.
73 class P2PManagerTest : public testing::Test {
74  protected:
75   P2PManagerTest() = default;
76   ~P2PManagerTest() override = default;
77 
78   // Derived from testing::Test.
SetUp()79   void SetUp() override {
80     loop_.SetAsCurrent();
81     FakeSystemState::CreateInstance();
82     async_signal_handler_.Init();
83     subprocess_.Init(&async_signal_handler_);
84     test_conf_ = new FakeP2PManagerConfiguration();
85 
86     // Allocate and install a mock policy implementation in the fake Update
87     // Manager.  Note that the FakeUpdateManager takes ownership of the policy
88     // object.
89     mock_policy_ = new chromeos_update_manager::MockPolicy();
90     fake_um_.set_policy(mock_policy_);
91 
92     // Construct the P2P manager under test.
93     manager_.reset(P2PManager::Construct(test_conf_,
94                                          &fake_um_,
95                                          "cros_au",
96                                          3,
97                                          TimeDelta::FromDays(5)));
98   }
99 
100 #if BASE_VER < 780000  // Android
101   base::MessageLoopForIO base_loop_;
102   brillo::BaseMessageLoop loop_{&base_loop_};
103 #else   // CrOS
104   base::SingleThreadTaskExecutor base_loop_{base::MessagePumpType::IO};
105   brillo::BaseMessageLoop loop_{base_loop_.task_runner()};
106 #endif  // BASE_VER < 780000
107   brillo::AsynchronousSignalHandler async_signal_handler_;
108   Subprocess subprocess_;
109 
110   // The P2PManager::Configuration instance used for testing.
111   FakeP2PManagerConfiguration* test_conf_;
112 
113   chromeos_update_manager::MockPolicy* mock_policy_ = nullptr;
114   chromeos_update_manager::FakeUpdateManager fake_um_;
115 
116   unique_ptr<P2PManager> manager_;
117 };
118 
119 // Check that IsP2PEnabled() polls the policy correctly, with the value not
120 // changing between calls.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,P2PEnabledInitAndNotChanged)121 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, P2PEnabledInitAndNotChanged) {
122   EXPECT_CALL(*mock_policy_, P2PEnabled(_, _, _, _));
123   EXPECT_CALL(*mock_policy_, P2PEnabledChanged(_, _, _, _, false));
124 
125   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->IsP2PEnabled());
126   brillo::MessageLoopRunMaxIterations(MessageLoop::current(), 100);
127   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->IsP2PEnabled());
128 }
129 
130 // Check that IsP2PEnabled() polls the policy correctly, with the value changing
131 // between calls.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,P2PEnabledInitAndChanged)132 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, P2PEnabledInitAndChanged) {
133   EXPECT_CALL(*mock_policy_, P2PEnabled(_, _, _, _))
134       .WillOnce(DoAll(SetArgPointee<3>(true),
135                       Return(chromeos_update_manager::EvalStatus::kSucceeded)));
136   EXPECT_CALL(*mock_policy_, P2PEnabledChanged(_, _, _, _, true));
137   EXPECT_CALL(*mock_policy_, P2PEnabledChanged(_, _, _, _, false));
138 
139   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->IsP2PEnabled());
140   brillo::MessageLoopRunMaxIterations(MessageLoop::current(), 100);
141   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->IsP2PEnabled());
142 }
143 
144 // Check that we keep the $N newest files with the .$EXT.p2p extension.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,HousekeepingCountLimit)145 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, HousekeepingCountLimit) {
146   // Specifically pass 0 for |max_file_age| to allow files of any age. Note that
147   // we need to reallocate the test_conf_ member, whose currently aliased object
148   // will be freed.
149   test_conf_ = new FakeP2PManagerConfiguration();
150   manager_.reset(P2PManager::Construct(test_conf_,
151                                        &fake_um_,
152                                        "cros_au",
153                                        3,
154                                        TimeDelta() /* max_file_age */));
155   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->CountSharedFiles(), 0);
156 
157   base::Time start_time = base::Time::FromDoubleT(1246996800.);
158   // Generate files with different timestamps matching our pattern and generate
159   // other files not matching the pattern.
160   for (int n = 0; n < 5; n++) {
161     base::FilePath path = test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append(
162         base::StringPrintf("file_%d.cros_au.p2p", n));
163     base::Time file_time = start_time + TimeDelta::FromMinutes(n);
164     EXPECT_EQ(0, base::WriteFile(path, nullptr, 0));
165     EXPECT_TRUE(base::TouchFile(path, file_time, file_time));
166 
167     path = test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append(
168         base::StringPrintf("file_%d.OTHER.p2p", n));
169     EXPECT_EQ(0, base::WriteFile(path, nullptr, 0));
170     EXPECT_TRUE(base::TouchFile(path, file_time, file_time));
171   }
172   // CountSharedFiles() only counts 'cros_au' files.
173   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->CountSharedFiles(), 5);
174 
175   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->PerformHousekeeping());
176 
177   // At this point - after HouseKeeping - we should only have
178   // eight files left.
179   for (int n = 0; n < 5; n++) {
180     string file_name;
181     bool expect;
182 
183     expect = (n >= 2);
184     file_name = base::StringPrintf(
185         "%s/file_%d.cros_au.p2p", test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value().c_str(), n);
186     EXPECT_EQ(expect, utils::FileExists(file_name.c_str()));
187 
188     file_name = base::StringPrintf(
189         "%s/file_%d.OTHER.p2p", test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value().c_str(), n);
190     EXPECT_TRUE(utils::FileExists(file_name.c_str()));
191   }
192   // CountSharedFiles() only counts 'cros_au' files.
193   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->CountSharedFiles(), 3);
194 }
195 
196 // Check that we keep files with the .$EXT.p2p extension not older
197 // than some specific age (5 days, in this test).
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,HousekeepingAgeLimit)198 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, HousekeepingAgeLimit) {
199   // We set the cutoff time to be 1 billion seconds (01:46:40 UTC on 9
200   // September 2001 - arbitrary number, but constant to avoid test
201   // flakiness) since the epoch and then we put two files before that
202   // date and three files after.
203   base::Time cutoff_time = base::Time::FromTimeT(1000000000);
204   TimeDelta age_limit = TimeDelta::FromDays(5);
205 
206   // Set the clock just so files with a timestamp before |cutoff_time|
207   // will be deleted at housekeeping.
208   FakeSystemState::Get()->fake_clock()->SetWallclockTime(cutoff_time +
209                                                          age_limit);
210 
211   // Specifically pass 0 for |num_files_to_keep| to allow any number of files.
212   // Note that we need to reallocate the test_conf_ member, whose currently
213   // aliased object will be freed.
214   test_conf_ = new FakeP2PManagerConfiguration();
215   manager_.reset(P2PManager::Construct(test_conf_,
216                                        &fake_um_,
217                                        "cros_au",
218                                        0 /* num_files_to_keep */,
219                                        age_limit));
220   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->CountSharedFiles(), 0);
221 
222   // Generate files with different timestamps matching our pattern and generate
223   // other files not matching the pattern.
224   for (int n = 0; n < 5; n++) {
225     base::FilePath path = test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append(
226         base::StringPrintf("file_%d.cros_au.p2p", n));
227 
228     // With five files and aiming for two of them to be before
229     // |cutoff_time|, we distribute it like this:
230     //
231     //  -------- 0 -------- 1 -------- 2 -------- 3 -------- 4 --------
232     //                            |
233     //                       cutoff_time
234     //
235     base::Time file_date = cutoff_time + (n - 2) * TimeDelta::FromDays(1) +
236                            TimeDelta::FromHours(12);
237 
238     EXPECT_EQ(0, base::WriteFile(path, nullptr, 0));
239     EXPECT_TRUE(base::TouchFile(path, file_date, file_date));
240 
241     path = test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append(
242         base::StringPrintf("file_%d.OTHER.p2p", n));
243     EXPECT_EQ(0, base::WriteFile(path, nullptr, 0));
244     EXPECT_TRUE(base::TouchFile(path, file_date, file_date));
245   }
246   // CountSharedFiles() only counts 'cros_au' files.
247   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->CountSharedFiles(), 5);
248 
249   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->PerformHousekeeping());
250 
251   // At this point - after HouseKeeping - we should only have
252   // eight files left.
253   for (int n = 0; n < 5; n++) {
254     string file_name;
255     bool expect;
256 
257     expect = (n >= 2);
258     file_name = base::StringPrintf(
259         "%s/file_%d.cros_au.p2p", test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value().c_str(), n);
260     EXPECT_EQ(expect, utils::FileExists(file_name.c_str()));
261 
262     file_name = base::StringPrintf(
263         "%s/file_%d.OTHER.p2p", test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value().c_str(), n);
264     EXPECT_TRUE(utils::FileExists(file_name.c_str()));
265   }
266   // CountSharedFiles() only counts 'cros_au' files.
267   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->CountSharedFiles(), 3);
268 }
269 
CheckP2PFile(const string & p2p_dir,const string & file_name,ssize_t expected_size,ssize_t expected_size_xattr)270 static bool CheckP2PFile(const string& p2p_dir,
271                          const string& file_name,
272                          ssize_t expected_size,
273                          ssize_t expected_size_xattr) {
274   string path = p2p_dir + "/" + file_name;
275   char ea_value[64] = {0};
276   ssize_t ea_size;
277 
278   off_t p2p_size = utils::FileSize(path);
279   if (p2p_size < 0) {
280     LOG(ERROR) << "File " << path << " does not exist";
281     return false;
282   }
283 
284   if (expected_size != 0) {
285     if (p2p_size != expected_size) {
286       LOG(ERROR) << "Expected size " << expected_size << " but size was "
287                  << p2p_size;
288       return false;
289     }
290   }
291 
292   if (expected_size_xattr == 0) {
293     ea_size = getxattr(
294         path.c_str(), "user.cros-p2p-filesize", &ea_value, sizeof ea_value - 1);
295     if (ea_size == -1 && errno == ENODATA) {
296       // This is valid behavior as we support files without the xattr set.
297     } else {
298       PLOG(ERROR) << "getxattr() didn't fail with ENODATA as expected, "
299                   << "ea_size=" << ea_size << ", errno=" << errno;
300       return false;
301     }
302   } else {
303     ea_size = getxattr(
304         path.c_str(), "user.cros-p2p-filesize", &ea_value, sizeof ea_value - 1);
305     if (ea_size < 0) {
306       LOG(ERROR) << "Error getting xattr attribute";
307       return false;
308     }
309     char* endp = nullptr;
310     long long int val = strtoll(ea_value, &endp, 0);  // NOLINT(runtime/int)
311     if (endp == nullptr || *endp != '\0') {
312       LOG(ERROR) << "Error parsing xattr '" << ea_value << "' as an integer";
313       return false;
314     }
315     if (val != expected_size_xattr) {
316       LOG(ERROR) << "Expected xattr size " << expected_size_xattr
317                  << " but size was " << val;
318       return false;
319     }
320   }
321 
322   return true;
323 }
324 
CreateP2PFile(string p2p_dir,string file_name,size_t size,size_t size_xattr)325 static bool CreateP2PFile(string p2p_dir,
326                           string file_name,
327                           size_t size,
328                           size_t size_xattr) {
329   string path = p2p_dir + "/" + file_name;
330 
331   int fd = open(path.c_str(), O_CREAT | O_RDWR, 0644);
332   if (fd == -1) {
333     PLOG(ERROR) << "Error creating file with path " << path;
334     return false;
335   }
336   if (ftruncate(fd, size) != 0) {
337     PLOG(ERROR) << "Error truncating " << path << " to size " << size;
338     close(fd);
339     return false;
340   }
341 
342   if (size_xattr != 0) {
343     string decimal_size = std::to_string(size_xattr);
344     if (fsetxattr(fd,
345                   "user.cros-p2p-filesize",
346                   decimal_size.c_str(),
347                   decimal_size.size(),
348                   0) != 0) {
349       PLOG(ERROR) << "Error setting xattr on " << path;
350       close(fd);
351       return false;
352     }
353   }
354 
355   close(fd);
356   return true;
357 }
358 
359 // Check that sharing a *new* file works.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,ShareFile)360 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, ShareFile) {
361   const int kP2PTestFileSize = 1000 * 8;  // 8 KB
362 
363   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->FileShare("foo", kP2PTestFileSize));
364   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("foo"),
365             test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append("foo.cros_au.p2p.tmp"));
366   EXPECT_TRUE(CheckP2PFile(test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value(),
367                            "foo.cros_au.p2p.tmp",
368                            0,
369                            kP2PTestFileSize));
370 
371   // Sharing it again - with the same expected size - should return true
372   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->FileShare("foo", kP2PTestFileSize));
373 
374   // ... but if we use the wrong size, it should fail
375   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->FileShare("foo", kP2PTestFileSize + 1));
376 }
377 
378 // Check that making a shared file visible, does what is expected.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,MakeFileVisible)379 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, MakeFileVisible) {
380   const int kP2PTestFileSize = 1000 * 8;  // 8 KB
381 
382   // First, check that it's not visible.
383   manager_->FileShare("foo", kP2PTestFileSize);
384   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("foo"),
385             test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append("foo.cros_au.p2p.tmp"));
386   EXPECT_TRUE(CheckP2PFile(test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value(),
387                            "foo.cros_au.p2p.tmp",
388                            0,
389                            kP2PTestFileSize));
390   // Make the file visible and check that it changed its name. Do it
391   // twice to check that FileMakeVisible() is idempotent.
392   for (int n = 0; n < 2; n++) {
393     manager_->FileMakeVisible("foo");
394     EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("foo"),
395               test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append("foo.cros_au.p2p"));
396     EXPECT_TRUE(CheckP2PFile(test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value(),
397                              "foo.cros_au.p2p",
398                              0,
399                              kP2PTestFileSize));
400   }
401 }
402 
403 // Check that we return the right values for existing files in P2P_DIR.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,ExistingFiles)404 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, ExistingFiles) {
405   bool visible;
406 
407   // Check that errors are returned if the file does not exist
408   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("foo"), base::FilePath());
409   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetSize("foo"), -1);
410   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetExpectedSize("foo"), -1);
411   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->FileGetVisible("foo", nullptr));
412   // ... then create the file ...
413   EXPECT_TRUE(CreateP2PFile(
414       test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value(), "foo.cros_au.p2p", 42, 43));
415   // ... and then check that the expected values are returned
416   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("foo"),
417             test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append("foo.cros_au.p2p"));
418   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetSize("foo"), 42);
419   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetExpectedSize("foo"), 43);
420   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->FileGetVisible("foo", &visible));
421   EXPECT_TRUE(visible);
422 
423   // One more time, this time with a .tmp variant. First ensure it errors out..
424   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("bar"), base::FilePath());
425   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetSize("bar"), -1);
426   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetExpectedSize("bar"), -1);
427   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->FileGetVisible("bar", nullptr));
428   // ... then create the file ...
429   EXPECT_TRUE(CreateP2PFile(
430       test_conf_->GetP2PDir().value(), "bar.cros_au.p2p.tmp", 44, 45));
431   // ... and then check that the expected values are returned
432   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetPath("bar"),
433             test_conf_->GetP2PDir().Append("bar.cros_au.p2p.tmp"));
434   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetSize("bar"), 44);
435   EXPECT_EQ(manager_->FileGetExpectedSize("bar"), 45);
436   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->FileGetVisible("bar", &visible));
437   EXPECT_FALSE(visible);
438 }
439 
440 // This is a little bit ugly but short of mocking a 'p2p' service this
441 // will have to do. E.g. we essentially simulate the various
442 // behaviours of initctl(8) that we rely on.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,StartP2P)443 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, StartP2P) {
444   // Check that we can start the service
445   test_conf_->SetInitctlStartCommand({"true"});
446   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->EnsureP2PRunning());
447   test_conf_->SetInitctlStartCommand({"false"});
448   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->EnsureP2PRunning());
449   test_conf_->SetInitctlStartCommand(
450       {"sh", "-c", "echo \"initctl: Job is already running: p2p\" >&2; false"});
451   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->EnsureP2PRunning());
452   test_conf_->SetInitctlStartCommand(
453       {"sh", "-c", "echo something else >&2; false"});
454   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->EnsureP2PRunning());
455 }
456 
457 // Same comment as for StartP2P
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,StopP2P)458 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, StopP2P) {
459   // Check that we can start the service
460   test_conf_->SetInitctlStopCommand({"true"});
461   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->EnsureP2PNotRunning());
462   test_conf_->SetInitctlStopCommand({"false"});
463   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->EnsureP2PNotRunning());
464   test_conf_->SetInitctlStopCommand(
465       {"sh", "-c", "echo \"initctl: Unknown instance \" >&2; false"});
466   EXPECT_TRUE(manager_->EnsureP2PNotRunning());
467   test_conf_->SetInitctlStopCommand(
468       {"sh", "-c", "echo something else >&2; false"});
469   EXPECT_FALSE(manager_->EnsureP2PNotRunning());
470 }
471 
ExpectUrl(const string & expected_url,const string & url)472 static void ExpectUrl(const string& expected_url, const string& url) {
473   EXPECT_EQ(url, expected_url);
474   MessageLoop::current()->BreakLoop();
475 }
476 
477 // Like StartP2P, we're mocking the different results that p2p-client
478 // can return. It's not pretty but it works.
TEST_F(P2PManagerTest,LookupURL)479 TEST_F(P2PManagerTest, LookupURL) {
480   // Emulate p2p-client returning valid URL with "fooX", 42 and "cros_au"
481   // being propagated in the right places.
482   test_conf_->SetP2PClientCommand(
483       {"echo", "http://1.2.3.4/{file_id}_{minsize}"});
484   manager_->LookupUrlForFile(
485       "fooX",
486       42,
487       TimeDelta(),
488       base::Bind(ExpectUrl, "http://1.2.3.4/fooX.cros_au_42"));
489   loop_.Run();
490 
491   // Emulate p2p-client returning invalid URL.
492   test_conf_->SetP2PClientCommand({"echo", "not_a_valid_url"});
493   manager_->LookupUrlForFile(
494       "foobar", 42, TimeDelta(), base::Bind(ExpectUrl, ""));
495   loop_.Run();
496 
497   // Emulate p2p-client conveying failure.
498   test_conf_->SetP2PClientCommand({"false"});
499   manager_->LookupUrlForFile(
500       "foobar", 42, TimeDelta(), base::Bind(ExpectUrl, ""));
501   loop_.Run();
502 
503   // Emulate p2p-client not existing.
504   test_conf_->SetP2PClientCommand({"/path/to/non/existent/helper/program"});
505   manager_->LookupUrlForFile(
506       "foobar", 42, TimeDelta(), base::Bind(ExpectUrl, ""));
507   loop_.Run();
508 
509   // Emulate p2p-client crashing.
510   test_conf_->SetP2PClientCommand({"sh", "-c", "kill -SEGV $$"});
511   manager_->LookupUrlForFile(
512       "foobar", 42, TimeDelta(), base::Bind(ExpectUrl, ""));
513   loop_.Run();
514 
515   // Emulate p2p-client exceeding its timeout.
516   test_conf_->SetP2PClientCommand(
517       {"sh",
518        "-c",
519        // The 'sleep' launched below could be left behind as an orphaned
520        // process when the 'sh' process is terminated by SIGTERM. As a
521        // remedy, trap SIGTERM and kill the 'sleep' process, which requires
522        // launching 'sleep' in background and then waiting for it.
523        "cleanup() { kill \"${sleep_pid}\"; exit 0; }; "
524        "trap cleanup TERM; "
525        "sleep 5 & "
526        "sleep_pid=$!; "
527        "echo http://1.2.3.4/; "
528        "wait"});
529   manager_->LookupUrlForFile("foobar",
530                              42,
531                              TimeDelta::FromMilliseconds(500),
532                              base::Bind(ExpectUrl, ""));
533   loop_.Run();
534 }
535 
536 }  // namespace chromeos_update_engine
537